WPA/25044/2025 of SUSANTA NASKAR Vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
20.01.2026
Item No.11
Ct. No. 30
Aloke
WPA 25044 of 2025
Susanta Naskar
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Tauhikd Khan
Mr. Atanur Halder
..for the petitioner
Ms. Aparna Banerjee
…for the respondent/P.F. Authority
Mr. Ghanshyam Pandey (through VC)
… for the Delta
1. The writ application has been preferred by
the petitioner/workman praying for direction upon
the respondents to release and disburse the rest of
37% Provident Fund amount and upto date interest
and all other dues including the Provident Fund dues
along with all other retrial benefit, along with the
interest @ 12% per annum towards the delayed
payment of retrial/provident fund benefits.
2. In course of hearing the learned counsel
appearing for the Provident Fund Commissioner has
submitted that the exemption of the establishment in
this case was withdrawn in the year 2023 and part of
the fund maintained by the company has been
transferred to the Provident Fund Commissioner and
the authority respondent no. 2 has already processed
the payment of all the workmen in respect of the said
dues on pro rata basis.
2
3. Learned counsel appearing for the
respondent/company submits that they have
transferred a substantial amount to the RPF
authority after the exemption has been withdrawn
and are also trying to figure out how to transfer the
balance amount as they are in a financial crisis.
4. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the
RPF Authority that after the order dated 01.07.2025
was passed in WPA 19510 of 2023 and a bunch of
matters, the amount transferred by the private
respondent company herein has already been
disbursed in full on pro rata basis as per the direction
of the Court in the said order.
5. It is now submitted by the learned counsel
for the RPF Authority that at present there is no fund
remaining with the RPF Authority to disburse or to
consider the claim of the petitioner.
6. Accordingly, on instructions, Ms. Banerjee
prays for direction upon the private respondent to pay
the outstanding amount in instalments so as to
enable the Provident Fund Authority to disburse the
outstanding amount.
7. Thus, on hearing all the parties and
considering the submissions made, the writ
application is disposed of with the direction that the
private respondent/company herein shall approach
the RPF Authority within 15 days from the date of
this order praying for easy instalments to transfer the
3
funds so as to enable the RPF Authorities to consider
the claim of the petitioner which may be done on pro
rate basis.
8. It is made clear that in case the respondent
company does not approach the RPF Authorities
within 15 days as directed, the RPF Authority shall be
at liberty to proceed in accordance with law against
the said company.
9. In case the company transfers the fund as
per instalments granted by the RPF Authority, who
shall do so when the petitioner appears before the
RPF Authority as directed, then the RPF Authority
shall proceed to take all necessary steps to disburse
the amount transferred by the company to the RPF
authority in favour of the workman on pro rata basis,
on compliance of all formalities by the
petitioner/workman as required by the authority
concerned.
10. The petitioner is thus directed to approach
the RPF authority and comply with all the formalities
to receive his proportionate dues. It is further directed
that the petitioner shall be at liberty to pray for
further relief by making an appropriate application
before the authority concerned as and when further
sum is transferred to the RPF authority by the
company.
11. Writ application stands disposed of.
4
12. Connected application, if any, stands
disposed of.
13. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
14. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order,
if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)